Crochet Amigurumi Starfish: Easy Keychain and Pincushion Pattern with Video

Finished crochet amigurumi starfish in white and aqua cotton with a navy starfish keychain

A crochet starfish is one of those tiny projects that ends up being far more useful than its size suggests. Clip it to a set of keys, hang it from a bag strap, or keep it next to your sewing kit as a soft little pincushion. This amigurumi starfish from Crochet Cabin covers all three, and it works up in one relaxed sitting.

The design is beginner friendly. You crochet the five-armed star flat, add a contrast border, then join the pieces and give them a light stuffing so the starfish stays plump but still flat enough to sit nicely on a table. Because the finished piece is only about 3 inches across, it is also a great way to use up small amounts of cotton left over from bigger projects.

Finished crochet amigurumi starfish in white and aqua cotton with a navy starfish keychain

Images and patterns courtesy of Crochet Cabin

25 Cutest and Sweetest Amigurumis ebook
From the Urbaki Store
Love amigurumi? Get 25 adorable patterns in one illustrated guide.
An illustrated page for every project with a direct link to the free pattern, plus 2 printable bonus guides. Free updates and a 60-day money-back guarantee.
See what's inside →
Want 5 new ideas every week? Try The Crochet Club free for 30 days.

Crochet Amigurumi Starfish at a Glance

  • Designer: Crochet Cabin (YouTube: @crochetcabin6160)
  • Skill level: Beginner
  • Finished size: about 3 in / 8 cm across
  • Yarn used in the video: Lion Brand Coboo, light weight (#3), 51% cotton and 49% rayon from bamboo, in white and lichen
  • Hook: E/3.5 mm
  • Video length: about 19 minutes

What You'll Need

  • Light weight (#3) cotton or cotton blend yarn in two colors, one for the star and one for the border
  • An E/3.5 mm crochet hook
  • A small handful of polyester fiberfill (the designer uses Fairfield)
  • A yarn needle for joining and weaving in ends
  • Scissors
  • Optional: a keyring, lobster clasp or bag charm hook if you want to turn your starfish into an accessory

A smooth cotton blend like the one in the video gives crisp stitch definition and a slight sheen, which suits a sea creature. Any light weight cotton will work, as long as you pair it with a hook that gives you a firm fabric. Tight stitches matter here, because they keep the stuffing hidden.

White crochet starfish keychain held up to show its five arms

How the Starfish Comes Together

1. Introduction (0:00 to 0:34)

The video opens with a look at several finished starfish in different color combinations, including one made into a keychain. It is a nice moment to decide on your own colors before you start.

2. Creating the star shape (0:34 to 4:24)

This is where the starfish gets its five arms. Each arm is shaped right off the center, so take your time on the first one and count carefully. Once you have the rhythm of a single arm, the remaining four go quickly. If an arm looks shorter or longer than the others, it is usually a missed or extra stitch, so check before moving on.

Working the arms of a crochet starfish with aqua cotton yarn and a 3.5 mm hook

3. Adding the border (4:24 to 10:01)

A round of contrast color around the edge is what makes this starfish look finished. The border follows every point and dip of the star, so watch how the designer works into the tips and the inner corners. This outline also gives the piece a little more structure, which helps it keep its shape after stuffing.

4. Joining and filling (10:01 to the end)

In the last section the pieces are joined around the edges and stuffed as you go. Add the fiberfill in small pinches and push it into each arm with the back of your hook or a pencil. Stop before the starfish feels hard: a softer fill keeps it flat, which is ideal for a pincushion or a charm that will sit against a bag.

Crochet starfish front with its contrast border finished, next to the crochet hook

Tips for a Neat Little Starfish

  • Go down a hook size if needed. If you can see gaps between your stitches, try a smaller hook. Gaps show the stuffing, especially with white yarn.
  • Count the arms as you work. Pause after each arm and check the stitch count. Five even arms make the difference between a starfish and a lopsided blob.
  • Choose border colors with contrast. Aqua on white, navy on white or coral on cream all look great and make the outline stand out.
  • Stuff lightly for pincushions. A firm but not overfilled starfish holds pins well and will not lose its flat shape.
  • Attach hardware securely. If you add a keyring, sew it through several stitches at the tip of an arm so it can take daily wear.
  • Make a set. Starfish look lovely in groups, so consider a few in different colors for a beach themed garland or as small gifts.

About the Designer

Crochet Cabin, shown on YouTube as Cabana de Ganchillo, shares calm, close-up tutorials for baskets, granny squares, accessories and little gifts. The camera stays on the hands the whole time, which makes it easy to follow along stitch by stitch. The designer asks that the pattern is used for personal use only. You are welcome to make starfish for yourself or as gifts, and if you share your work, credit Crochet Cabin and link back to the original video tutorial.

Enjoy the Video Tutorial

Source: Crochet Cabin

Frequently Asked Questions

How big is the crochet starfish?

With light weight cotton and a 3.5 mm hook, the finished starfish measures about 3 inches (8 cm) across. A thicker yarn and a bigger hook will give you a larger starfish without changing the steps.

Is this starfish suitable for beginners?

Yes. The designer describes it as an easy tutorial for beginners, and it uses basic stitches. The trickiest part is shaping the arms evenly, and the video shows that slowly and clearly.

What can I use a crochet starfish for?

The video presents it as a keychain, a pincushion and a handbag charm. It also works as a gift tag, an ornament for a summer tree or part of a nautical garland.

More from Crochet Cabin

Maggie Johnson

Maggie Johnson is a crochet enthusiast who has been crafting with yarn for over a decade. While she's not a professional, Maggie finds joy in exploring new patterns, experimenting with colors, and creating handmade gifts for friends and family. On this blog, she shares her passion for crochet, offering tips, tutorials, and inspiration for fellow hobbyists, whether you're a beginner or have been stitching for years. Maggie believes in the beauty of handmade creations and the calming power of crochet.

More crochet projects for you

Go up